Hey everyone...sorry, I had been stricken with the flu (or so I think) and instead of pushing myself, decided I should rest, which proved to be quite beneficial. Anyway...here you go, an unedited version of comments I wrote during class.
• What is your story about? Are the details you selected true to that focus?
My story is about my family’s lake house, although not in the describing sense. Rather, I focus on the area surrounding the cottage. I detail the experiences I had while driving up there recently and other features of the landscape, one of which is a gorge that flows into the lake.
I’m still not sure if the details are true to the focus. I want them to be as sharp as possible but feel they need to be polished. While I do believe in what I have written, I don’t think this is the final version. I have modified it a little but have yet to analyze all the words.
• Are there any "facts" which you are uncertain of which you have set forward as true?
All of the episodes I have written have happened at some point in my life. Whether they happened in order or in a collaboration of memories is a question which I may have to dig deeper into. There are many pictures of the area and they help to serve as a journal of our vacations. Also, there is a journal that everyone writes something in while they are up there. I really should have mentioned this in the piece. This would definitely help tie in the lineage that my family has within this house.
• Have you made changes in setting, time, or sequence which are unacknowledged?
This is a question that I may have some issues with. I don’t know if I need to include a time frame for each episode or if I can leave it as a “I remember” sort or period, sometime in the past.
Perhaps this may be the greatest weakness I have with this piece. That I never really forge a time frame other than the present, past and when I was seven. Also, did that flower scene really happen when I was nine. There could be many times that happened. In fact, I think we tried the float various things down the stream a lot. This wasn’t just an isolated incident but rather a continuing saga until my sister became too old to participate in such foolishness. How would I go about doing this as I get ready to revise this again? Would I have to relate the history of us playing at the creek. This could dangerous as I have no clue how to begin this, let alone what I would say. Grr! This sucks a lot as I have way too much to write but want to confine it to the most poignant parts.
• Have you fabricated dialog which you cannot remember (without acknowledging that you do not remember exact words)?
No, I have no dialogue within my piece so I do not need to remember this.
• Have you written your experience - or does your story cast you in terms of a "type" (like Frey)?
This I’m not quite sure of yet. In the beginning, I say I leave behind my technologies which I did. Did I make a conscious effort to leave them? I don’t think so; it just never occurred to me to bring them or at least some of them. I purposely left my lap-top at home but everything else…I’m not sure. I think I grabbed my razor because I like the close shave and the refreshing feeling, not that I didn’t want my electric razor. I had my guitar so I didn’t need my iPod. Is it wrong to say that I left these when I’m obviously leading the reader to believe that they just complicate my life?
The only other section I may be concerned with is the Mennonite section. Why do I think this? Well, I guess because I’m still a boy who remembers seeing these plain people. I didn’t quite know how to react. Should I write my reaction? If so, how did I react? I believe that I was in awe more of the horse-carriage than the people. I was amazed that horses were used in real life and not just in the movies. I mean…I knew of horses from the 4-H fair but only saw them in a contained environment never being used for practical purposes. What does this mean?
• Are there relevant details which you deliberately left out? Why did you leave them out? Anything you are trying to avoid?
There are lots of details. Did I leave anything out? That’s hard to say. I could say yes but then might have to think that it may be my subconscious trying to avoid any dangerous details. However, the purpose of my piece is more of a larger question than a reflection on me. So what is my relation to this place? This is my sun for the summer. I have gone to Disney and Washington D.C., Toronto and Niagra Falls. But my summers are always more fulfilling at the lake. Should I write in these trips? Should I say how, although educational, were not quite the lake.